53. Tim Cahill (2004-present)
That it would cost ten Cahills to buy one Robbie Keane shows not the gulf in class between the two players but the brilliance of this David Moyes signing. Strong and unfeasibly dominant in the air for someone who is only 5ft 10in, Cahill has an unreal knack for goalscoring. The Australian is the competitive heart of the current Everton team and is often pushed to an emergency centre-forward position. Whether he is scoring a last-minute overhead kick, leaping into the stands to sign autographs on foreign tours, or mussing the hair of young and wide-eyed fans, he is always doing it for the team. Evertonians love Cahill and you get the impression that the feeling is very much mutual.
